Cancellation of Certificates of Public Convenience for Common Carriers; Failure to Operate or Report Any Operating Revenue
[48 Pa.B. 7357]
[Saturday, November 24, 2018]
Public Meeting held
November 8, 2018
Commissioners Present: Gladys M. Brown, Chairperson; Andrew G. Place, Vice Chairperson; Norman J. Kennard; David W. Sweet; John F. Coleman, Jr.
Cancellation of Certificates of Public Convenience for Common Carriers; Failure to Operate or Report Any Operating Revenue; M-2018-3003742
By the Commission:
On August 23, 2018, the Commission entered a Tentative Order in the above-captioned proceeding to initiate the process for cancelling the Certificates of Public Convenience (CPC) of common carriers that failed to file required annual assessment reports and/or failed to establish that they have operated continuously. The Tentative Order was mailed to each carrier and was published in the Pennsylvania Bulletin on September 8, 2018. 48 Pa.B. 5683. Carriers were given 20 days from publication to challenge the cancellation of their CPCs, file a conforming Assessment Report, or, alternatively, request cancellation of their CPCs.
The carriers that were served with the August 23 Tentative Order were those carriers that failed to respond to the Commission's earlier Secretarial Letter dated May 31, 2018, requesting that they either file an assessment report detailing their intrastate operating revenues, as required by Section 510 of the Public Utility Code, 66 Pa.C.S. § 510, or notify the Commission of their desire to abandon their CPCs. Moreover, the Secretarial Letter warned the carriers that failure to comply would result in the Commission taking appropriate action to cancel their CPCs.
By way of background, the Public Utility Code requires that by March 31 of each year, every public utility must file a report detailing its gross intrastate operating revenue for the preceding calendar year. 66 Pa.C.S. § 510(b). This report is essential for the Commission to fund its operations and to properly allocate assessment costs among the regulated utility community. Id. In addition, common carriers are required to operate continuously and without unreasonable interruptions of service. 66 Pa.C.S. § 1501, 52 Pa. Code §§ 29.61-62. A carrier with no intrastate operating revenues for several years indicates that it is no longer providing jurisdictional public utility service in Pennsylvania and, therefore, a CPC for that entity is no longer ''necessary or proper for the service, accommodation, convenience, or safety of the public.'' 66 Pa.C.S. § 1103(a). In addition, Commission regulations authorize the cancellation of a common carrier's CPC for failure to comply with operating and reporting requirements, as well as other provisions of the Public Utility Code. 52 Pa. Code §§ 29.12 (Motor Carriers of Passengers) and 31.12 (Motor Carriers of Property).
In response to the August 23 Tentative Order, the common carriers listed in Table 1 filed a conforming Assessment Report with the Commission reporting their gross intrastate operating revenue for 2017; the common carriers listed in Table 2 filed an Assessment Report with the Commission reporting no gross intrastate operating revenue for 2017; the common carriers listed in Table 3 requested cancellation of their CPCs; and the common carriers listed in Table 4 did not respond to the Tentative Order in any way. The carriers listed in Table 5 appeared on the August 23 Tentative Order. However, their CPCs have already been cancelled through Commission action taken either shortly before or since publication of the Tentative Order in the Pennsylvania Bulletin. No further action is required with respect to these carriers.
The carriers listed in Table 1 are in compliance with the reporting requirements of 66 Pa.C.S. § 510(b) and the operational requirements of 66 Pa.C.S. § 1501 and 52 Pa. Code §§ 29.61-62. Therefore, this matter is closed with respect to these carriers. The carriers listed in Table 2 are provisionally in compliance with our reporting requirements. Therefore, this matter is closed with respect to these carriers. However, since these carriers may not be operating continuously, as required by Section 1501 of the Public Utility Code, 66 Pa.C.S. § 1501, and Sections 29.61-62 of the Commission's regulations, 52 Pa. Code §§ 29.61-62, they are advised that they must operate and report revenues from their operations or appropriate action will be taken against them.
Finally, the carriers listed in Tables 3 and 4 have either requested cancellation of their CPCs or have failed to respond to the Tentative Order, remaining in non-compliance. Moreover, each of these carriers have failed to report any intrastate operating revenues for several years. A carrier with no intrastate operating revenues for several years indicates that it is no longer providing jurisdictional public utility service in Pennsylvania and, therefore, a CPC for that entity is no longer ''necessary or proper for the service, accommodation, convenience, or safety of the public.'' 66 Pa.C.S. § 1103(a). Each of these carriers have had ample notice and an opportunity to be heard via the May 31, 2018 Secretarial Letter and the August 23, 2018 Tentative Order. The carriers listed in Table 3 requested that their CPCs be cancelled. None of the carrier listed in Table 4 responded. The CPCs of both groups will be cancelled; Therefore,
It Is Ordered That:
1. This matter is closed for motor carriers listed in Table 1.
2. Motor carriers listed in Table 2 will provisionally retain their Certificates of Public Convenience and this matter is closed with respect to these carriers. These carriers are advised that they must operate and report revenues from their operations or appropriate action will be taken against them.
3. The Certificate of Public Convenience for each motor carrier listed in Table 3 is cancelled at the carrier's request. These carriers shall be stricken from all active utility lists maintained by the Commission's Bureau of Technical Utility Services and the Fiscal & Assessments Section of the Bureau of Administration.
4. The Certificate of Public Convenience for each motor carrier listed in Table 4 is cancelled for noncompliance with the reporting and operating requirements of the Public Utility Code and Commission regulations. These carriers shall be stricken from all active utility lists maintained by the Commission's Bureau of Technical Utility Services and the Fiscal & Assessments Section of the Bureau of Administration.
5. The Secretary serve a copy of this Final Order upon the Bureau of Investigation & Enforcement, the Bureau of Technical Utility Services, the Bureau of Administration, Department of Revenue—Bureau of Corporation Taxes, Department of Transportation, and all motor carriers listed in Tables 1—4. The Final Order shall be filed at each carrier's docket number.
6. The Secretary shall publish a copy of this Final Order in the Pennsylvania Bulletin.
Table 1—Carriers That Reported 2017 Revenue
Utility Code Carrier Name Docket No. 6412387 VALLEY FORGE LIMO CO., LLC A-2010-2185476,
6413168 AMERIQUEST AMBULANCE, INC. A-2010-2195604 6414780 MED TRANSIT, LLC A-2012-2310335 6416457 WYOMISSING CAR SERVICE AND TAXI, LLC A-2014-2413704 6416543 COLONIAL LIBERTY CAB CO., LLC A-2014-2421267 641706 CLOUD 9 TRANSPORTATION, INC. A-00123125,
701666 BARON, JOLANN A-00112604 703845 KLEIN, DAVID J., INC. A-00116007 706024 BAYLOR, JEROME P. A-00119454 707507 ANTHONY BADER (BNT MOVERS, LLC) A-00122066,
708823 HORNING, JASON L. A-00124052 890053 FOULK MATERIAL HANDLING, INC. A-00108695 8910173 IVAN'S TRUCKING CORPORATION A-2008-2043862 8911383 T & C TOWING & RECOVERY, LLC A-2009-2130902 8915122 WHEELS EXPRESS, INC. A-2012-2325276 8915610 E K SERVICES, INC. A-2013-2355506 8917628 EUGENE M SNYDER
T/A SNYDERS MOBILE SERVICES
A-2015-2479119 8917719 JTL TRUCKING, INC. A-2015-2484370 8917770 PAUL E. SCHAEFFER TRUCKING, INC. A-2015-2488192 8918050 WILLIAM MARTINEZ, LLC A-2015-2503248 899888 CEMPORT, INC. A-2008-2025346
Table 2—Carriers That Reported No 2017 Revenue
Utility Code Carrier Name Docket No. 6416039 LEGACY LIMOUSINE, LLC A-2014-2410656 741340 DUDISH, WILLIAM L. A-00099005 899987 K E D S MATERIALS AND CONTRACTING, INC. A-2008-2035139
Table 3—Carriers: Certificates of Public Convenience Cancelled by Request
Utility Code Carrier Name Docket No. 8913640 DBT ENTERPRISES, LLC A-2011-2247122 8913869 JOHN BARNEY III & DONNA E. BARNEY A-2011-2260260
Table 4—Carriers: Certificates of Public Convenience Cancelled for Non-compliance
Utility Code Carrier Name Docket No. 630400 ODDY TRANSPORTATION SERVICE, INC. A-00109796 6311476 D M L CAB CO. A-00114160 6311480 T & W CAB CO. A-00121193 6315127 LEROY CAMPBELL & JAVIAN A. ARMSTRONG, CO-PARTNERS A-2012-2325313 632252 GOLF TAXI, INC. A-00119600 632418 PROSHA CAB CO. A-00120182 632474 BESIKTAS, INC. A-00120403 639040 YAFIM CAB COMPANY A-00106042 640031 ALLWAYS TRANSPORTATION, INC. A-2011-2230899 640483 TERRY R. MARTIN (T/A EAST WIND LIMOUSINE) A-00113345 640721 SACKS, JAMES O., INC. A-00115805 6410139 TREKKIE TRANSPORTATION, INC. A-2008-2042010 6410249 GERMANTOWN EMISSION & INSPECTION STATION, LLC A-2008-2049714 6411202 VICTOR CARBE, JR.
T/A ROLLS ROYCE RENTAL
A-2009-2114783 6411208 THE PITTSBURGH TOUR COMPANY, LLC A-2009-2115042 6411461 A-1 VAN SERVICE, INC. A-2017-2583562 6411640 NEWBERRY TOWNSHIP FIRE DEPARTMENT A-2009-2147630 641320 CASHDOLLAR, LEON J. A-00120485 641365 CATAWESE COACH LINES, INC. A-2010-2198624 6413770 C.R. WILKERSON, LLC A-2011-2255598 6413814 WORLD CLASS RIDE, LLC
T/A WORLD CLASS RIDE
A-2011-2257843 6414251 ABDELKARIM BAROUDI A-2012-2287493 6414512 DAVON CHRISTIAN A-2012-2296719 6414623 EMINENT MEDICAL TRANSPORT, INC. A-2012-2302918 6414635 HAZLETON AMBULETTE SERVICES A-2012-2303448 6414676 SILVER STAR COACH & LIMOUSINE, LLC A-2012-2304728 641469 SIRAWAN TRANSPORTATION, INC. A-00121676,
6415105 CORNERSTONE MEDICAL TRANSPORT, LLC A-2012-2323974 6415272 LX TRANSPORTATION, LLC A-2012-2334197 6415377 SAFE RIDES, LLC A-2012-2340010 6415996 AMBULANCE SERVICE OF AMERICA, INC. A-2013-2382310 641620 CELEBRITY LIMOUSINES, LLC A-00122589 6416222 KRK TRANSPORTATION GROUP, LLC A-2013-2398206 6416238 ELITE EMS, INC. A-2014-2399311 6416372 ARRIVALS 365, LLC A-2014-2408112 6416880 MAO & ED BUS SERVICE, INC. A-2014-2440863 641693 VALLEY LIMOUSINE SERVICE, LLC A-00123058 6416944 PANICHELLI EXECUTIVE SERVICES, INC. A-2014-2444319 6417118 TOP CARE TRANSPORTATION, INC. A-2014-2456142 6417544 USA SHUTTLE SERVICE, INC. A-2015-2475681 641772 SUPERSTAR COACH, INC. A-00123469 641808 WELSH, JODI MARIE A-00123708 641828 RIDES, INC. A-00123819 648190 WILLIAMS BUS LINES CO. A-00100861 649814 KANE TRANSPORTATION SERVICES, INC. A-2008-2024166 690142 SAFECARE AMBULANCE SERVICES, INC. A-00119122 700006 MCILVAINE TRUCKING, INC. A-00108526 700055 FIGURSKI, GERALD N. A-00108685 700252 J. J. MALONEY CO. A-00109207 700324 TRANS TECH LEASING, INC. A-00108189 700559 QUAKER CITY PRODUCE CO. A-00110223 700786 BOWER, DON E., INC. A-00111002 700966 BUD TRANSPORT, INC. A-00111684 701040 ADVANCED TRANSFER, INC. A-00101795 701333 RIVERSIDE BUILDERS SUPPLY, INC. A-00112141 701391 E. G. SERVICE CO. A-00112211 701470 MATSON, BYRON D. A-00112307 701635 MICHAEL BOULDEN A-00112542 701697 SOUTH, JAMES E. A-00112659 701729 R & R EXPRESS, INC. A-00112702 701904 MAXWELL TANK LINES, INC. A-00112999 702004 FRED MOORE TRUCKING, INC. A-00113167 702048 GOGGIN MOVING, INC. A-00113228 702051 ZARELLI, PETE, EXCAVATING COMPANY A-00113231 702169 SMITH EZ TRUCKING COMPANY, LLC A-00113438 702206 NEON EXPRESS, INC. A-00113511 702334 DELLICH, DANIEL J., JR. A-00113687 702692 TROY M. GREEN A-00114247 702772 WISE MOBILE HOMESPECIALISTS, INC. A-00114398 702798 RAYGENE, INC. A-00114444 702809 THE TERMINAL CORPORATION A-00114463 702810 C & C DISTRIBUTION, INC. A-00114464 702909 GAST, ROBERT L. A-00114636 703146 SUREHAUL TRANSPORT, INC. A-00114968 703419 DEROSA TRUCKING, INC. A-00115329 703639 MARK A. KLINE A-00115696 703673 FUZZCO TRUCKING, INC. A-00115749 703787 CB HONEYWELL CONSTRUCTION A-00115921 703940 NICE CONTRACTORS, INC. A-00116189 703945 R.J.&J. ENTERPRISES, INC. A-00116194 703967 CORPORATE BANK TRANSIT OF KENTUCKY, INC. A-00116216 704095 WASTELINE CORPORATION A-00116416 704233 WILLARD P. FREDERICK A-00116622 704261 TAMURA, SHEILA A. A-00116655 704293 KEIBLER, TIMOTHY E. & DEXTER A. A-00116695 704355 THOMAS K. SIEMONS/KEYSTONE TOWING & REC. A-00116802 704570 MCCONNELL'S, INC. A-00117128 704727 RICHARD P. SMILEY
T/A RICHARD P. SMILEY TRUCKING
A-2010-2178055 704743 PARKS, SCOTT A-00117410 704814 WOMEX, INC. A-00117514 704900 BEVINGTON TRUCKING, INC. A-00117664 704936 BOWERS, ROBERT LEROY A-00117709 705047 MORNINGSTAR, SCOTT T. A-00117904 705134 JERRY DAVIS A-00118068 705246 MUIR, LISA L. A-00118218 705750 CHANCE, STANLEY E. A-00118975 705806 MOHAR, DAVID WAYNE A-00119100 705903 JAMES & DEBRA AMENT A-2015-2478404,
705957 THOMAS A. JOHNSON A-00119335 706051 MALTI, MALTI & GOODWIN, COPTS A-00119530 706295 MINTURN, WILLIAM C. A-00119974 706439 PETITTO, ANGELO J. A-00120230 706492 SCE ENVIRONMENTAL GROUP, INC. A-2013-2370249 706828 KRAMER ENTERPRISES, INC. A-00120929 706862 SIGMUND TRANSFER COMPANY, LLC A-00120984 707033 BOVANI'S TOWING AND SERVICE, INC. A-00121303 707281 JEFF BOYD TRUCKING, LLC A-00121783 707327 SHENK, MICHAEL L. A-00121836 707367 PERDEW, MICHAEL A., SR. A-00121887 707376 SIMONE, PASCAL S. A-00121900 707442 CREATIVE LAND CONCEPTS, INC. A-00121983 707467 ROADMASTERS TRANSPORT CO., L.P. A-00122020 707527 NILESKI, WILLIAM A-00122105 707553 ANTHONY RODILOSSO A-00122164 707660 RUNOVITZ TRUCKING, INC. A-00122317 707731 G. P. M. TRANSPORT, INC. A-00122427 707753 RONALD WICKWIRE A-00122461 707869 BRIAN SCOTT BODINE A-00122656 707976 YATES, JOHN W. A-00122776 708004 PISANO, MICHAEL EDWARD A-00122801 708062 ZECH'S TOWING & RECOVERY, LLC A-00122890 708109 SMITH, JOHN W. A-00122966 708147 GT LOGISTICS, LLC A-00123033 708169 BROWN, ROBERT A-00123068 708215 BRIAN E. MOORE A-00123141 708299 NAKUTIS, JAMES J. A-00123269 708371 NEDELJKO GUNJAK, INC. A-00123374 708402 WARNER, RANDY D. TRUCKING, INC. A-00123413 708403 SIEGLER, RICHARD O. A-00123415 708434 TABOR, MICHAEL J. A-00123465 708576 PULLER, ROBERT A-00123678 708628 MICHAEL STELLA A-00123767 708696 RED LION TRANSPORTATION, INC. A-2017-2638383 708808 ENVIRON. LANDSCAPING SERV, INC. A-00124024 708872 AVG SERVICES, INC. A-00124122 714150 BLANEY FARMS, INC. A-00107001 718240 BROCIOUS, CARL A-00098875 729872 COMMONWEALTH WAREHOUSE & STORAGE A-00104678 787630 LAMPARTER, INC. A-00104759 890061 KDK TRANSPORT, INC. A-00108750 890231 BARRETT'S TRANSPORTATION SERV. A-00109551 890354 BOGER, JOHN H., AND SON, INC. A-00110101 890371 ROBERT F. ALTEMOSE A-00110181 890458 BALKAN EXPRESS, INC. A-00110473 8910355 PINE GROVE ENTERPRISES, INC. A-2008-2056953 8910500 BIER BROTHERS ENTERPRISES, LLC A-2009-2137287 8910649 SALVAGE DIRECT, INC. A-2008-2079785 8910801 T TURNER TRANSPORT, INC. A-2014-2414817 8910808 NELSON LOGISTICS, LLC A-2009-2093365 8910919 AUTO TRIM-LINES OF PA, INC. A-2009-2095352 8911016 JOHN ELWOOD DORR
T/A DORR'S MOVING EXCHANGE
A-2009-2102501 8911111 JUSTIN R. STEFFEY A-2009-2108889 8911231 PENN AIR NOTCH SERVICES, INC. A-2009-2118011 8911444 JODY D. HOWE A-2009-2136026 8911756 ANDREJACK EXCAVATING, LLC A-2010-2156189 8911774 M K HEYER TRANSPORTS, LLC A-2010-2157905 8911817 PHILIP E. VOUGHT A-2012-2338596 8912182 PORLANICK, INC. A-2010-2177208 8912333 JANOS KOLTAY A-2010-2183315 8912400 MDF INDUSTRIES, INC. A-2010-2186436 8912580 SHADES OF GREEN, INC. A-2010-2193121 8912666 ARROW ENERGY SERVICES, INC. A-2010-2197772 8912678 ANTONIO WILLIAMS, SR. A-2010-2198320 8912794 ROBERT HARRINGTON HAULING, LLC A-2010-2201995 8912873 RODNEY R. RAUGHLEY EXCAVATING, LLC A-2010-2206262 8913001 FOLSE OILFIELD SERVICES, LLC A-2010-2206863 8913009 ROBERT A. STEMPA A-2010-2216339 8913245 MATTHEW BOWER TRUCKING, INC. A-2011-2229533 8913262 ERIC L. BERGER A-2011-2230311 8913271 JAMES WALTER SNYDER, JR. A-2011-2230866 8913429 BOWEN TRUCKING, LLC A-2011-2236854 8913475 J & L TRUCKING CORP. A-2011-2238146 8913535 GRANDVIEW LOGISTICS, LLC A-2011-2240746 8913574 BRUCE C. PATOCKA
DBA KRP TRUCKING & EXCAVATING
A-2011-2243364 8913656 BROWN BOYS TRUCKING, LLC A-2011-2271953 8913732 JENNIE J. TALARICO A-2011-2253132 8913735 RANDALL L. LUZIER A-2011-2253214 8913790 COMMERO TRUCKING, LLC A-2011-2256411 8913856 ALVERTON ENTERPRISES, LLC A-2015-2482202 8913873 WENGER WELL SERVICES, INC. A-2011-2260384 8913910 DAVID TCHUIGOUA SAGANG A-2011-2263851 8913961 ACE TRUCKING ENTERPRISES, LLC A-2011-2267153 8913987 ROMBERGER TRANSPORT, INC. A-2011-2269986 8914020 FEROA TRUCKING, LLC A-2011-2270954 8914046 PITTSBURGH SOUTHWESTERN TRUCKING, LLC A-2011-2271998 8914157 GREYHAN TRANSPORT, LLC A-2012-2281626 8914266 J D HARRIS TRUCKING, LLC A-2012-2288808 891444 PUBLICATION DIST. SERV., INC. A-00107308 8914521 WAYNE A. BRENDLINGER A-2012-2297295 8914526 JAMES HUGHES, JR. A-2012-2297620 8914677 KENNETH L. METZINGER A-2012-2304746 8914725 JTC TRANSPORT, LLC A-2012-2306302 8915010 BETHEL METALS & RECYCLING, INC. A-2012-2314868 8915053 NORDOL, INC. A-2012-2318483 8915106 IRON CITY LEASING, LLC A-2012-2323352 8915214 BRIAN K. SCOTT A-2012-2329815 8915328 SHAWN M. GOWIN A-2012-2337301 8915395 VIRTUE TRANSIT, LLC A-2013-2343023 8915400 SUMMIT SITE CONTRACTORS, INC. A-2013-2343231 8915606 VICTOR & JASMINE VEGA,
CO-TENANTS BY ENTIRETY
A-2013-2355263 8915723 SEAN BECK A-2013-2361737 8915834 DANIEL THOMAS TRANSPORTATION, LLC A-2013-2370656 8915861 SOVEREIGN TRANSPORT, INC. A-2013-2372941 8915886 PETROLEUM TRANSPORT, LLC A-2013-2374982 8916013 ROSS DISTRIBUTIONS, LLC A-2013-2383371 8916017 DENNIS SIZEMORE A-2013-2383681 8916099 REDBIRD TRUCKING, INC. A-2013-2390424 8916106 PAT REILLY TRUCKING, LLC A-2013-2390451 8916168 FOUR STARS PIPE AND SUPPLY, INC. A-2013-2395155 8916362 ARMONE R. HAMMONDS A-2014-2407503 8916419 MICHAEL MILLER A-2014-2411847 8916432 PRO-DIG ENTERPRISES, LLC A-2014-2412438 8916548 MGM TRUCKING, LLC A-2014-2422057 8916617 LIMIT BREAK, LLC A-2014-2426077 8916646 WEAKLAND'S MECHANIC SHOP, INC. A-2014-2427307 8916767 IRG DELIVERIES CORPORATION A-2014-2436432 8916876 DWM CARRIERS, INC. A-2014-2440428 8916939 D RICHARDSON TRUCKING, INC. A-2014-2444029 8916953 KENNY & SON'S TRANSPORTATION, LLC A-2014-2444444 8917135 ZIPPY SHELL LEHIGH VALLEY, INC. A-2014-2457110 8917203 OPAL EXPRESS, INC. A-2015-2483053 8917212 JOHNNY P. ONISKO A-2015-2460949 8917415 BORDER CONNECT FREIGHT SERVICES, INC. A-2016-2547311 8917446 BSL TRUCKING, LLC A-2015-2472145 8917454 NORTHSTAR UNLIMITED, LLC A-2015-2472481 8917516 DEREK STOLL A-2015-2512638 8917524 GT WORLDWIDE TRANSPORT, INC. A-2015-2475035 8917589 R & B TRUCKING SERVICES, LLC A-2015-2477783 8917592 R&B CONTRACTING & EXCAVATION, INC. A-2015-2477872 8917737 NICOLAAS F. AKKERMAN A-2015-2485789 8917784 MARK T. WEBER A-2015-2489090 8918110 1ST IMPRESSION LANDSCAPING, INC. A-2015-2505955 8918111 J & A DELIVERY, LLC A-2015-2505970 899931 FULL STAR ENTERPRISES, INC. A-2008-2028251
Table 5—Carriers: Certificates of Public Convenience Already Cancelled
Utility Code Carrier Name Docket No. 704255 RISTENBATT, INC. A-00116646 708082 FLOOD TRUCKING, LLC A-2012-2308485 708621 THE ACME COMPANY, INC. A-00123752 725050 CARUSO HAULING, INC. A-00103928 740440 DONALD ELWOOD DORR A-00091972 815860 OFFICE MOVERS, INC. A-00096937 8914648 NATIONAL TRANSPORT CARRIERS, INC. A-2012-2303632 8917211 JL LEASING, INC. A-2015-2460931,
[Pa.B. Doc. No. 18-1841. Filed for public inspection November 21, 2018, 9:00 a.m.]
No part of the information on this site may be reproduced for profit or sold for profit.
This material has been drawn directly from the official Pennsylvania Bulletin full text database. Due to the limitations of HTML or differences in display capabilities of different browsers, this version may differ slightly from the official printed version.